“I’ll be right down,” you say into the intercom. Then you look for your shoes and head down several flights of stairs. As you get to the door, the woman with your package already knows how long “right down” takes for that fifth-floor walk-up. She does this for a living and has been to your door before. Let’s call her Rose.
Now this Rose doesn’t work at Zabar’s. Her vest says Amazon, but she still works for a small, independently-owned New York delivery company of her own neighborhood’s making—a modern “Shop Around the Corner.” The people who own it hire the crew, run routes, and work hard to keep their business open and make payroll. That’s important in New York City, where keeping a small business open is a job all by itself.
In the movie “You’ve Got Mail,” Fox Books puts the Shop Around the Corner out of business through competition. But the New York City Council could do it with a vote, and the end result might mean New Yorkers will pay more to get their deliveries sent to their homes.
The Delivery Protection Act, or Intro 518, would generally force warehouse companies like Amazon that run covered delivery warehouses to hire drivers directly instead of hiring them through small business contractors.
Take Brimela Routes, one of more than 40 local companies that deliver these Amazon packages in New York. Amazon contracts with Brimela to get packages from the warehouse to your front door, apartment lobby, or mailroom. Right now, Brimela pays drivers. Brimela’s owner, Julissa Alvarez, told Gothamist she worries about the crew she’s already hired if her work goes in-house at Amazon.
Put yourself in the shoes of a Brimela employee. You might like your current boss and your route, know your coworkers, and have a job that works for you and your family. Under the bill, if Brimela loses that contract and can’t afford to employ you anymore, the warehouse company, such as Amazon, would have to give you an offer to do the same delivery work on its payroll.
So now City Hall is giving you a choice you never asked for. Either you can go to work for Amazon on its routes directly or start looking for another job. All this because politicians decided who needed to sign your paycheck.
Even if an existing contract qualifies for an extension and the drivers are on a contracted business’ payroll instead of being directly employed by a warehouse, the company would have to post a $500,000 bond for every delivery worker. Supporters are pushing this extreme regulation to “cover costs of lawsuit liabilities for accidents” they likely have insurance for anyway. For a crew of 20, that’s $10 million in bonding. But what company is going to take that on to keep a local delivery company’s contract?
It’s clear the real purpose is to make delivery contracting unviable as a business. Fox Books sold “cheap books and legal addictive stimulants” to get rid of its competition but these Shops Around the Corner will simply go out of business due to government red tape.
Customers will be stuck with the bill. The city transportation department says about four out of five New York City households get deliveries every week. If these warehouses leave the city for the suburbs, longer delivery routes could cost more. In a study, AKRF estimated that costs could go up by $409 per household per year if some of these operations move outside the city or $664 per year if all affected operations move.
This new program, even after license fees are collected, is projected to cost taxpayers $182,500 a year just to administer, according to the official impact statement. That’s before the dollars New Yorkers could see add up at checkout.
Amazon says local delivery partners employ about 5,000 people. For companies like Brimela that depend on that contract to make payroll, losing it could mean shutting their doors.
The rent is already too high. Council members need to vote down Intro 518 and let the Shop Around the Corner keep delivering.