Skip to main content

Government Ownership Is the Wrong Way to Strengthen the Defense Industrial Base

The Senate is currently considering its FY 2027 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), an annual bill that sets defense policy and authorizes military spending. At $1.15 trillion, this proposal represents a 28% increase from last year’s enacted levels and amounts to the largest defense authorization bill in history. And yet, the bill’s hefty price tag isn’t the only concern for taxpayers.

The FY 2027 NDAA would create a statutory framework allowing the Department of Defense (DoD) to acquire equity stakes in private companies—effectively putting taxpayers on the hook for bets on private businesses.

Tucked away deep in this sprawling legislative package is a section entitled “Equity Investments and Related Matters.” Section 1051 would authorize the Office of Strategic Capital (OSC) through 2037 to make equity investments in private companies deemed essential for national security. The bill creates a new “Department of Defense Equity Investment Account” at the Department of the Treasury to fund these investments. The OSC was created in 2022 to help support the development of critical defense technologies and domestic supply chains through loans and technical assistance. The NDAA bill being considered in the Senate would add direct equity investments to the government’s toolbox.

For years, Republicans have repeated the refrain that “America will never be a socialist country.” Those words ring hollow when the federal government is actively taking ownership stakes in private businesses. Government ownership of private enterprise is precisely the kind of government intervention Republicans have long warned against. How can Republicans expect the public to take their warnings about socialism seriously while simultaneously embracing policies that move us in that direction?

Supporters of this expanded authority argue that equity investments are a necessary tool to shore up the domestic defense industrial base. The COVID pandemic demonstrated just how fragile global supply chains can be. Shortages of consumer goods at the time were bad enough, but the stakes are even higher when national defense is concerned. Indeed, apprehension about relying on foreign countries for strategically-important materials and technologies during a national security emergency has already led the Pentagon to make multiple equity investments using various existing statutory authorities.

National security concerns surrounding supply chain vulnerabilities are perfectly valid, but they do not justify turning taxpayers into investors. If Congress thinks a particular industry is failing to attract enough funding from capital markets, it can always provide support through the regular appropriations process. While likely not advisable from a taxpayer perspective, the Pentagon already has the ability to provide grants to develop critical technologies and buttress supply chains. These existing mechanisms are important because they preserve legislative oversight and accountability for how taxpayer funds are spent.

Direct equity investments create unnecessary risks. Government ownership would distort the incentives behind federal policymaking. As a shareholder, the federal government would have a vested interest in rising valuations. This could potentially skew policy decisions in favor of government-backed companies rather than national security priorities.

Fiscal conservatives have long opposed government intervention in the economy that picks winners and losers. In a letter sent to congressional leaders earlier this month, a coalition of free-market and limited government advocates made it clear that codifying government ownership of equity stakes in private businesses would have deleterious consequences for the rule of law and national security.

Unfortunately, the Senate NDAA’s intervention in private markets does not end with equity investments. Section 815 would bar the DoD from entering into contracts with defense companies unless they agree to refrain from stock buybacks, issuing dividends, and other capital distributions. Stock buybacks and dividends play an important role in attracting the private capital that funds technological innovation. While the Pentagon would have the ability to issue waivers, this foray into industrial policy risks undermining the very investment needed to bolster the domestic defense industrial base.

Buttressing the American defense industrial base will require a steady supply of private investment. But government bureaucrats are a poor substitute for competitive markets when it comes to deciding where to allocate capital and which companies are best positioned for growth. Rather than expanding government power over private markets, Congress should establish clear and predictable rules that allow private capital to flow where it can be put to the best use. This would better serve the interests of taxpayers and American national security.