Skip to main content

America’s Air Traffic Control Problem Requires Reform, Not Another Bailout

This past weekend’s ground stop left millions of air travelers stranded, frustrated, and wondering how the nation’s aviation system could be so easily disrupted. Similarly, the Trump Administration’s request for $50 billion to “fix” the problem has also left taxpayers’ heads spinning. The solution to America’s outdated air traffic control system isn’t another significant cash injection. It’s fundamental reform, including removing air traffic control from the federal bureaucracy and establishing an independent, more efficient system that can better serve the flying public.

A blueprint for fixing the air traffic control (ATC) system should look like bipartisan legislation introduced in the first Trump term. That comprehensive proposal, the AIRR Act of 2017, would have transferred responsibility for operating, maintaining, and modernizing air traffic control from the FAA to the American Air Navigation Services Corporation, an independent, federally chartered nonprofit governed by a board representing aviation stakeholders. Rather than relying on annual congressional appropriations, the organization would have financed its operations through user fees and have been governed by aviation stakeholders and experts.

In fact, the United States is the only developed country that operates its ATC directly by a government agency. Other nations, including Canada and those in Europe, have separated ATC service delivery from government safety regulation.

As NTU and 23 other free market groups argued, if this transition were enacted, “consumers will experience fewer travel delays, the movement of goods will become more efficient, aircraft will burn less fuel, capacity will expand, responsiveness and transparency will improve, political micromanagement will recede, costs will be easier to control and sustain, and the economy could experience tens of billions of dollars in growth. Meanwhile, all facilities and the pilots who depend on them will benefit from speedy technological innovations that the new, non-bureaucratic entity would encourage. Furthermore, the FAA’s focus on regulating overall aviation safety would actually be sharper.”

That bipartisan bill never passed the House, but now would be as good a time as ever to get it to the president’s desk.

Unfortunately, neither Congress nor the Administration seem to be moving in that direction. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy instead is asking Congress for $50 billion in new funding to “modernize” the system while offering limited details about how those funds would be spent. Even more troubling, when he made the request, the Administration had yet to fully determine what caused the ground stop in the first place.

This is hardly a new phenomenon: Washington’s knee-jerk response is almost always to spend first and ask questions later.

Further federal spending on modernization is unlikely to solve the problem and could simply repeat the failures of the past. It is no exaggeration to call previous modernization efforts a resounding failure, marked by years of delays and billions of dollars in wasted taxpayer resources. The problem is laid bare in a recent Department of Transportation Inspector General report examining NextGen, the federal government’s early-2000s initiative to bring air traffic control into the twenty-first century. The IG concluded that “lengthy delays and cost growth have been a recurring feature of FAA’s modernization efforts through the course of NextGen’s over 20-year lifespan.” More than two decades later, NextGen remains plagued by delays and cost overruns, while its projected benefits have been repeatedly scaled back.

Americans depend on safe, reliable air transportation, and they deserve nothing less. Congress may be tempted to hand the Administration the $50 billion it is requesting simply to demonstrate that Washington is taking the problem seriously. But the better solution is to follow the lead of other countries by separating air traffic control from the federal bureaucracy, establishing a more efficient operating model, and pairing structural reform with targeted capital investments to modernize the system. Otherwise, that $50 billion risks becoming a first-class ticket to the taxpayer wasteland.