Statement for the Record
David Timmons, Senior Policy Manager, National Taxpayers Union
U.S. Senate Committee on the Budget
Regarding the Committee’s Hearing Entitled
“Social Security: The Reality”
November 18, 2026
Dear Chairman Johnson and Ranking Member Merkley,
Thank you for holding this hearing.
The title of this hearing is quite appropriate when considering the overall political environment surrounding the issue of the solvency of Social Security’s Trust Fund. Many on the political left believe a fix to Social Security can be found entirely on the tax side of the equation, while many on the right believe that appropriately dialing back benefit increases or focusing benefits on those most in need will provide all the answers. Unfortunately, or fortunately for those who believe in bipartisan policy results, neither side has all the answers here. Social Security was excluded from the congressional reconciliation process decades ago, for this very reason.
However, in recent months, groups on the left have started pressing for the idea of an “all-tax” solution to Social Security solvency. The AARP has come out against any benefit reductions as part of a solvency solution, even though benefits have risen higher than inflation for years. The group is promoting the idea of targeting non-wage forms of income, including returns from investments. This idea would, along with another idea that would eliminate the maximum amount of income that can be taxed by Social Security (the “tax max”), effectively destroy the very foundations of the program as designed by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt. FDR wanted Social Security to be seen as an “earned” benefit, directly tied to taxes on a future recipient’s wage income.
Eliminating the tax max is an unwise idea in the first place. With a full elimination of the taxable maximum, unless benefit levels are capped, the agency would eventually start sending out some very large checks. It is possible that SSA could send, for example, over $170,000 a year in Social Security benefits to someone who earned a million dollars a year in their working years. And this large tax increase would do great damage to the economy, permanently reducing economic output and jobs going forward. Proposals to increase payroll taxes would take earnings from current workers to increase benefit payments to current retirees, who typically already have a substantially higher net worth than younger households.
Moreover, as predicted by FDR, it would open up Social Security to the vagaries of partisan politics, eventually creating a permanent state of instability in the program. FDR himself wanted to keep a direct connection between payments and benefits, so Americans would feel a personal connection to the program. Therefore, in his words, “no damn politician can ever scrap my social security program.” Eliminating the tax max, and widening contributions to non-wage forms of income, would cause Social Security to be seen more like welfare, or, in FDR’s words, “relief.” Programs like these are much more prone to partisan warfare.
Most pragmatic individuals who work in the Social Security policy space—on the left and the right—recognize that a solvency solution that sticks will need to be bipartisan. The specific levers that get pulled in a future solution will depend on the members of Congress in the room when the deal is made, but what matters now is that these discussions begin as soon as possible.
We urge Congress to get serious about ensuring the long term solvency of Social Security: to stop the partisan games, accept the reality of this serious policy issue, and get started on working out a fix.
We stand ready to work with members of your Committee and others, and appreciate your focus on this important policy issue.