As Government Probe of Online Companies Continues, Poll Shows Americans Highly Satisfied with Search Options, Skeptical of RegulationFor Immediate Release March 7, 2012Pete Sepp
, (703) 683-5700Douglas Kellogg
, (703) 683-5700
VA) – When it comes to accessing the Internet, adults across America feel they
have many options for doing so, and are strongly opposed to government
regulation of online search functions. Those are the primary findings of an IBOPE
Zogby International poll commissioned by the 362,000-member National Taxpayers
Union (NTU), a nonpartisan citizen group. The poll was conducted between March
2nd and 5th, covering 2,007 respondents with a margin of
error of +/- 2.2 percentage points.
results could not speak more loudly or clearly: across numerous demographic
categories, Americans firmly believe the marketplace for finding information
online is highly competitive,” said NTU Executive Vice President Pete Sepp. “Equally
important, the overwhelming skepticism they’ve voiced over government
intervention in this marketplace should serve as a warning to policymakers who
are pursuing burdensome federal investigations of online search practices.”
results affirmed that consumers find information online in many ways: 84
percent of those polled use a search engine, 72 percent directly access a
website, 36 percent utilize social media, and 18 percent employ another method
such as a mobile phone application. But other questions probed issues of choice
and competition more deeply:
this wide range of choices, 87 percent agreed with the statement “I feel I can
easily switch to a competing search engine if I’m not happy with the results I
receive;” just 8 percent said they were “stuck with using a particular search
engine and don’t have the ability to switch.”
were then asked whether “the federal government should regulate the content and
appearance of search engines and their results.” A whopping 79 percent strongly
or somewhat disagreed with this idea, compared to 12 percent who strongly or
somewhat agreed. The depth of opposition was striking – 64 percent strongly
disagreed versus just 3 percent who strongly agreed.
were presented with arguments about more enforcement of federal antitrust laws,
and then asked to choose which statement was most true. A massive 76 percent agreed
that “More government involvement and regulation will make the Internet worse
for consumers,” while just 8 percent thought that such involvement and
regulation “will make the Internet better for consumers.”
over government’s role in the Internet was present among all major demographic
groups, including age, income, educational attainment, and even ideology.
Self-identified liberals still expressed opposition to both search engine
regulation and increased antitrust enforcement by roughly 3 to 1 margins. The
trend was similar for those declaring themselves Democrats.
- Democrats felt the government should NOT regulate the "content and appearance of search engines and their results" by an overwhelming 68 percent. Democrats also strongly aligned against more government involvement and regulation, with 56 percent saying it would make the internet worse for consumers. Republicans more strongly disagreed with government regulation of search engines with 89 percent (77 percent strongly disagreed). The self-identified Republicans almost uniformly agreed "government involvement and regulation will make the internet worse for consumers" as 94 percent registered that response.
- Broken down by political ideology: 64 percent of 'Liberals', 79 percent of 'Moderates', and 88 percent of 'Conservatives' disagreed with more federal regulation of "the content and appearance of search engines and their results." When judging whether "more enforcement of federal antitrust laws will make the Internet more competitive and responsive to consumers," 51 percent of Liberals said such measures would make the Internet worse, as did 73 percent of Moderates, and 93 percent of Conservatives.
- Younger generations are more strident in their opposition to government regulation. 88 percent of 18-29 year olds opposed government regulation of the content and appearance of search engines, as did 79 percent of 30-49 year olds, 75 percent of 50-64 year olds, and 74 percent of 65 years and older. 81 percent of the 18-29 age group felt "more government involvement and regulation will make the internet worse for consumers"; compared to 77 percent of 30-49 year olds, 74 percent of 50-64 year olds, and 70 percent of those older than 65.
During the late 1990s and early 2000s, NTU was a leading grassroots
participant in the antitrust debate from the conservative community, advocating
policies that stress consumer freedom, private-sector innovation, and limited
government involvement. Last year the group expressed concern over Federal
Trade Commission investigations of the online search marketplace. Full poll results and more demographic breakdowns are available HERE and HERE.