America's independent, non-partisan advocate for overburdened taxpayers.

 

Blog Contributors

Brandon Arnold
Executive Vice President 

Dan Barrett
Research and Outreach Manager 

Melodie Bowler
Government Affairs Intern 

Demian Brady
Director of Research 

Christina DiSomma
Communications Intern 

Jihun Han
Communications Intern 

Timothy Howland
Creative Content Manager 

Samantha Jordan
Communications Intern 

Curtis Kalin
Communications Intern 

Ross Kaminsky
Blog Contributor 

David Keating
Blog Contributor 

Douglas Kellogg
Communications Manager 

Sharon Koss
Government Affairs Intern 

Michael Liguori
Government Affairs Intern 

Richard Lipman
Director of Development 

Joe Michalowski
Government Affairs Intern 

Diana Oprinescu
Communications Intern 

Austin Peters
Communications Intern 

Kristina Rasmussen
Blog Contributor 

Expert Panel Shoots Straight on Missile Defense


Pete Sepp
September 24, 2012

As regular readers of “Government Bytes!” will remember, National Taxpayers Union has often contended that by spending smarter instead of just harder on ballistic missile defense programs, elected officials can protect the nation’s finances as well as its citizens. For example, we’ve been encouraging Congress to concentrate funding for the Standard Missile-3 (SM-3) component of the Aegis defense platform on the “IB” and “IIA” variants rather than the somewhat tenuous “IIB” version. Our commentary appearing on The Hill’s Congress Blog earlier this month praised Senate Appropriators for doing just that:

Increases in overall missile defense spending notwithstanding, Senators were right to direct resources toward the next generation of SM-3, known as Block IB, instead of the more futuristic IIB version (which received a cut of $169 million). After a challenging first test in the development phase, Block IB has met with several successes, including two difficult intercepts this year. …Meanwhile, Block IIB remains an ambitious design that is confined more to the drawing board than the test range. … [A]ll Senators ought to agree upon setting budget priorities for systems that can maintain a predictable cost pattern between now and the end of the decade. On this score, SM-3 Block IB holds better promise than Block IIB.

Others share NTU’s opinion on this matter, from a similar fiscal standpoint. In April, six conservative organizations joined us on an NTU-led open letter to Congress that stated:

Over our organizations’ histories we have encountered projects throughout the armed services that promised massive technological advancements for warfighters, only to yield underwhelming   results, behind-schedule evolution, and overinflated price tags. … Highly risky ventures like Block IIB often take similar trajectories – all offer huge potential on paper, many are kept alive long after that potential fades, and few have fiscal outcomes that are acceptable to overburdened taxpayers.

Recently this stance received a vindication of sorts from a report authored by the National Research Council for the National Academy of Sciences entitled, “Making Sense of Ballistic Missile Defense: An Assessment of Concepts and Systems for U.S. Boost-Phase Missile Defense in Comparison to Other Alternatives.”

Given the government’s penchant for studying problems rather than solving them, it is a miracle more American taxpayers aren’t injured from becoming entangled in all the blue ribbons shed from the multitude of commissions in Washington. But as The New York Times explained, the findings represent “the first time that the research council – an arm of the National Academy of Sciences, chartered by Congress to give scientific and technical advice to the government and considered the nation’s preeminent group of scientists – has weighed in on the nation’s overall plans for defeating missile attacks.” The 16-member panel included engineers, scientists, and other experts from think tanks, academic institutions, and the defense industry.

Their conclusion, laid out in more than 250 technical and jargon-filled pages, was that the current approach to missile defense needs an adjustment to stress “evolutionary” approaches using existing systems and practical, proven designs. Calling the recommendations “a major blow to President Obama’s strategy,” which NTU has also criticized, the Times reported that the panel is calling for a “stronger domestic system” of sensors and ground-based interceptors that would abandon step four of the current “Phased Adaptive Approach” (PAA). Although the National Research Council’s document is a veritable alphabet soup of acronyms, one section describes the panel’s conclusion in relatively simple terms:

Phase 4 of PAA … is an expensive solution for improving homeland defense yet limited in effectiveness. The committee’s analysis shows that notional interceptors with a fly-out velocity greater than 4.5km/sec benefit neither European defense nor other Aegis defense missions. Therefore, Phase 4 of PAA, which is the SM-3 Block IIB higher performance interceptor, has value only for an early shot opportunity for homeland defense, provided it has sufficient burnout velocity to preclude being overflown, but comes at a high acquisition and life-cycle cost. [The panel’s] alternative – an evolved GMD [Ground-Based Midcourse Defense] system – provides a more effective homeland defense solution and avoids any need for Phase 4 of PAA.

The Times noted that the report claims the National Research Council’s strategy “could fit within current antimissile spending – which runs about $10 billion a year – if the military eliminated what the panel describes as costly and unneeded systems.” Still, the report cites somewhat higher life-cycle costs with its plan, meaning that Congress would need to examine the details carefully to ensure that stewardship of tax dollars remained a top priority. Other offsetting reductions might be necessary. Despite these caveats, the bottom line is becoming more and more evident: a missile-defense plan that relies on maturing technologies like SM-3 Blocks IB and IIA is a better move than gambling on systems like IIB with less predictable cost and performance patterns. Now Congress needs to demonstrate it’s willing to learn from these findings rather than roll the dice with more tax dollars at stake.


 

Comment on this blog

Nickname
Comment
Enter this word:

User Comments

Submitted by Anonymous at: August 26, 2014
Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge. click resources

Submitted by jassica at: August 22, 2014
Business theories seem to be in a realm all their own, but what they actually are is another matter altogether. The idea behind a business theory is a situation or result that has been proven true time and time again in various business settings. businesstheory

Submitted by jassica at: August 22, 2014
Let's face it, all business's have their up's and downs. It could be financial, it could be new employees or the old employees are not cutting it anymore. And it could be that your clientele is not the way that it use to be. minoritybusinesssolutions

Submitted by jassica at: August 22, 2014
Going green is not just a trend, it is a smart decision that both consumers and businesses benefit from. Ironically, many of the environmentally beneficial solutions are also economically beneficial. smartgreenbusiness

Submitted by Anonymous at: August 21, 2014
Finally, an issue that I am passionate about. I have looked for information of this caliber for the last several hours. Your site is greatly appreciated. go to this web-site

Submitted by Harrsion at: August 21, 2014
I found this post very exciting. I think you will have any other post on this topic? The trails can be linked together for an 18 mile loop that takes visitors deep into the mountains http://buyesogoldonline.weebly.com/ | http://theelderscrollsonlinegold.jigsy.com/

Submitted by web at: August 21, 2014
too shy to get a girlfriend Girlfriend Activation System Review: web's #1 girlfriend system (GFAS V2) by Christian H. teaches you how to get a girlfriend by activating her obsession story. visit my website http://girlfriendactivationsystemreviews.com/ ...

Submitted by Aditech at: August 19, 2014
This is my first opportunity to visit this website I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog. best home warranty company

Submitted by Aditech at: August 19, 2014
The world is changing fast. people are also being changed.day by day we are becoming more dependant on degital system.yoU make me think of this really.You have a nice way of sharing your thoughts. personal trainer mallorca

Submitted by ERISOR78 at: August 17, 2014
Puis il a étudié les sciences politiques au Collège de Claremont Men et s'inscrit au Collège de Marin pour étudier le théâtre. Il a gagné une bourse pour étudier à la prestigieuse Juilliard Institut de New York, où il a passé trois ans à enseigner le théâtre de professeurs de renom tels que John Houseman. Il est retourné à San Francisco avant l'obtention du diplôme. Sly Collection ps vita Son objectif était de devenir un acteur dramatique, mais n'a pas réussi à obtenir des rôles à remplir. Il se tourna vers la comédie stand-up et de gagner vous-même, travaillant dans les bars et dans un magasin de crème glacée.

Submitted by buy traffic cheap at: August 16, 2014
You are a very professional blogger. I’ve joined your feed and sit up for in search of more of your excellent post. buy traffic cheap

Submitted by my review here at: August 16, 2014
Really great. You are absolutely welcome. And thank you for coming by! I really appreciate it.my review here

Submitted by website at: August 15, 2014
michael fiore's online allure formula Online Allure Formula: Michael Fiore Reveals His Fool-Proof, Step-By-Step System For Meeting Amazing Men Online... Written for consumers by a consumer, this fan site includes a fun and informative Online Allure Formula review, ebook FAQ, and PDF download guide that provides an insider's look at the program and answers frequently asked questions about Michael Fiore's unique and highly popular online dating guide. Please visit website https://www.rebelmouse.com/onlineallureformulareviews/ ...

Submitted by sfgsdag at: February 16, 2013
http://www.coachoutletonlinexusa.com/ Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet
http://www.shopcoachfactory.com/ shop.coachfactory.com coachfactory.com/shop Coach Store Online
http://www.michaelkorsooutlet.com/ Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online
http://www.guccishoesinuk.com/ Gucci Shoes UK Gucci Shoes Outlet