Skip to main content

Up Next for the Keystone State: Steeling Wealth and Soaring Taxes?

As we talked about last week, the midterm elections that just took place will continue to have implications for policymaking in many states for years to come. Arguably, the state where that has become most immediately apparent is Pennsylvania.

Already, progressive groups in the state have begun lobbying for all the old progressive favorites in the Keystone State: a “Fair Share Tax” replacing the state’s flat income tax rate with a bifurcated rate that would tax capital gains income at more than double the rate of other types of income, reviving previously-dead and still-unconstitutional digital advertising taxes, making a renewed push for worldwide combined reporting, and more.

But, while post-election progressive wishcasting may yet founder when it comes time to push radical legislation through narrow majorities in Harrisburg, the state’s two football cities are busy winding up to throw their own Hail Marys.

Pittsburgh’s Tax on Things It Can’t Tax

Taxing investment income seems to be all the rage in Pennsylvania, because Pittsburgh is also contemplating a new tax on passive income. The only problem: the state constitution expressly forbids Pittsburgh from doing that.

Pennsylvania’s 3.07% statewide income tax rate has always been misleading, as most cities and counties append significant local rates on top. In Pittsburgh, the 3.07% statewide rate is supplemented by a 2% school district tax and a 1% city-level tax. While the statewide tax applies to all types of income, the state prohibits localities from taxing anything other than “earned income,” such as wages or self-employment income.

Councilmember Barb Warwick has proposed a draft bill (imaginatively also called the “Fair Share Tax”) to tax “unearned income” (such as capital gains) at a 2% rate at the city level. When combined with the identically-named proposal at the federal level, it would result in a significantly higher tax rate on passive income than active income.

“Fair Share Tax” Plans Would Not Be Very Fair

Income Tax Rates for Pittsburgh Residents under Current Law and the “Fair Share Tax” Proposals

 

Current Law

“Fair Share Tax” Plan

 

Earned Income Tax Rate

Unearned Income Tax Rate

Earned Income Tax Rate

Unearned Income Tax Rate

Statewide

3.07%

3.07%

2.80%

7.50%

City

1.00%

0.00%

1.00%

2.00%

School District

2.00%

0.00%

2.00%

0.00%

Total

6.07%

3.07%

5.80%

9.50%

The policy issues with targeting investment income for special tax rates could be the topic of their own email, so, for now, let’s focus on that constitutional impediment mentioned earlier. A legal memo has been making the rounds suggesting that these long-understood constitutional barriers are a mirage, but expect some lawyers here at NTUF to explain the issues with that assumption shortly.

Philadelphia’s Luddite Tax on Automation

Not to be outdone, a draft bill in Philadelphia’s city council would levy significant new taxes on automated services—such as a minimum of $0.50 on robotic deliveries and $1 on robotaxi rides. Automated freight delivery would face a 3% tax on gross receipts for the portion of the trip mileage within Pittsburgh city limits. If that last one seems bizarre and confusing to you, that’s because it is.

Beyond just being strange, these “robot taxes” would necessarily be paid by Yinzers. Making local residents pay more to subsidize what are often temporary, part-time jobs is not much of an “affordability” solution.

Hopefully Pennsylvania and its sub-jurisdictions move past the “no bad ideas” part of the brainstorming phase soon. Because, you know, there are definitely some bad ideas.