Congress relies on the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to examine federal spending and to provide oversight of executive agencies. President Trump’s nominee to lead GAO may be well qualified, but the statutory selection process was not followed, raising concerns about the independence of the legislative branch’s top watchdog. The next Congress should strengthen its oversight of GAO and reform how the Comptroller General is selected to ensure meaningful, bipartisan deliberation.
As NTU and the Project On Government Oversight (POGO) explained in a joint guide to how the selection process is supposed to work, federal law establishes a bipartisan, bicameral commission to recommend three candidates for Comptroller General. The Comptroller General leads GAO as Congress’s independent, nonpartisan watchdog which is responsible for auditing federal agencies, investigating the use of taxpayer dollars, reporting on waste and duplication, and evaluating programs while providing administrative and legislative recommendations to improve operations.
The commission includes congressional leaders and the chairs and ranking members of the House and Senate oversight committees. The president then selects a candidate for Senate confirmation for a 15-year term. The president is not obligated to pick a candidate nominated by the commission.
This time, the deliberative process was short-circuited. The bicameral commission was not convened to consider nominees. Instead, on November 11, 2026, Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee Chairman Rand Paul (R-KY) requested candidate submissions from commission members with a short time frame to respond. On November 16, President Trump nominated Eric Ueland for Comptroller General and a nomination hearing was scheduled for November 19.
Ueland brings three decades of public service experience in both Congress and the executive branch. He currently serves as the deputy director of the White House’s Office of Management and Budget and previously served as a staff director at the Senate Budget Committee and chief of staff to Republican leaders Bill Frist and Don Nickles. This background gives him a familiarity with federal budgeting, agency management, and how Congress operates.
However, Ueland’s experience does not resolve questions about the rushed selection process or his ability to move from partisan roles to leading a nonpartisan watchdog organization. Some lawmakers, stakeholders, and even former Comptrollers General have objected to how the nomination is proceeding. If the hearing goes forward, taxpayers deserve clear assurances that GAO will remain independent and hold agencies accountable. The following recommendations can help address these concerns:
Give the Nominee Fair Consideration. Ueland’s congressional and executive branch experience deserves serious evaluation. His ability to lead the agency and Congress’s handling of the appointment are separate questions. During the hearing set for this Thursday, taxpayers want to hear the nominee explain how he would safeguard GAO’s independence while serving Congress.
Address the Process in the New Congress. The statutory process calls for a committee of representatives and senators to propose three candidates for the Comptroller General. However, the president is not obligated to select from those three. Since GAO is Congress’s chief watchdog, lawmakers could look to revise the selection process in the next Congress.
Strengthen Congressional Oversight of GAO. In the 120th Congress, the House and Senate committees responsible for overseeing GAO should regularly review its performance and independence to ensure it fulfills its mission to safeguard taxpayer dollars.
Congress and the executive branch should collaborate closely to reduce waste and ensure that taxpayer dollars are spent wisely and efficiently. GAO should play a pivotal role by providing independent analysis of agencies across the executive branch. Congress should look at reforming the selection process to ensure meaningful deliberation and consideration from Congress and the president while securing GAO’s independence. Taxpayers need an effective, independent watchdog that follows the facts and holds agencies accountable, regardless of which party controls Washington. An overhaul of the nomination process would strengthen Congress’s voice in selecting its watchdog and help preserve GAO’s independence for years to come.