Congressional Budget Office (CBO) Director Phillip Swagel announced today that he will return to his faculty position at the University of Maryland after his second term ends in January. Leading CBO is a difficult assignment. Swagel deserves recognition for his service to Congress and taxpayers since taking the helm in 2019.
Because of its pivotal role in policy making, CBO is one of the most important agencies in Washington. Its estimates help lawmakers assess the costs of legislation, and its budget and economic outlooks show the consequences of allowing spending and debt to continue on their current path. The usefulness of that work depends on the agency’s credibility and its willingness to explain its findings, assumptions, and the areas of uncertainty around them.
Just two years before Swagel became director, CBO faced a serious threat to its credibility. In 2017, criticism of its health care estimates led to House amendments to slash its funding, with some calling for private think tanks to take over its scoring work. While both these amendments failed, they underscored the need to improve CBO’s reputation and analyses. Swagel’s predecessor, Keith Hall, responded by expanding outreach and transparency efforts, laying groundwork that Swagel would build upon.
Under Swagel, CBO has built on the work of previous directors to make its methods and assumptions more accessible. The agency has released more computer code, expanded its modeling tools where possible, and provided more information to help Congress and researchers examine its estimates and assumptions.
One example of a simple yet meaningful transparency improvement was to give uncertainty greater prominence in CBO’s estimates, placing an overview summary directly underneath the main tables that show spending and revenue impacts. The topline dollar figures grab the headlines so readers should also be able to easily see the factors that could cause different outcomes from CBO’s projections. As before, the texts of the reports provide additional information about these uncertainties.
The House and Senate Budget Committees traditionally alternate the lead in recommending a CBO director for a four-year term. That person is then formally appointed jointly by the Speaker and the Senate’s president pro tempore. Under this rotation, the incoming Chair of the Senate Budget Committee is expected to lead the selection in the 120th Congress next January. As candidates to succeed Swagel are considered, several qualities should be prioritized.
Independence and professional credibility. The next director must apply consistent analytical standards regardless of which party sponsors a proposal or controls Congress. Lawmakers need reliable information on the state of the budget and proposals that are up for consideration.
A commitment to transparency. Publishing an estimate should be accompanied by clear explanations of its assumptions, methods, and uncertainty. The next director should continue expanding access to models and underlying data.
Responsiveness and clear communication. Technical expertise should be paired with the ability to explain CBO’s analyses and methodologies in order to engage effectively with lawmakers, congressional staffers, and policy stakeholders.
CBO often draws criticism from both sides of the aisle, but many concerns about its estimates stem from the rules that Congress requires it to follow. Those rules can distort the budget baseline and obscure the costs of legislation as members game the system with gimmicks. That is why NTUF has recommended reforms that CBO can implement directly, along with statutory changes lawmakers should enact, to improve the agency’s analysis and the broader budget process.
These reforms include reporting debt-service costs in legislative scores, expanding use of dynamic scoring, and preventing temporary emergency spending from being carried forward in the baseline. NTUF also recommends closing loopholes that let lawmakers claim extensions of routinely renewed fees as offsets for unrelated spending. Together, these changes would give lawmakers and taxpayers a clearer picture of federal finances and fewer opportunities to hide spending behind budget gimmicks.
Dr. Swagel deserves thanks for his work strengthening CBO. His successor should build on that progress so that Congress and taxpayers have better information about the costs and consequences of federal policy.